Color is beautiful, but this smudges easily, esp if you have oily eyelids. Came out pretty matte on me, you can only see the shimmer very, very up close. Not good if you like precise lines on your eyeliner. Buffs out to a nice color so I use it like an eyeshadow and always top it with setting powder. I'll use up this bottle but I won't repurchase.
I usually use a felt-tip pen. This one is applied according to a completely different principle, you need to practice a little and you will get wonderful arrows! Once upon a time, my favorite eyeliner was from Yves Rocher, but this brand hasn't left the rashist market, so I haven't bought anything there for a long time)))) And it's so nice to watch how their stores close one by one, because the boycott of everything related to rashits works wonders)))